Struggling to find the perfect eyeliner?

It's no secret that cake eyeliners are trending right now. You know how they can make your eyes pop, but with so many options on the market, it can be hard to decide which one is best for you. Let us help! We've tested out five of the most popular cake eyeliners and will reveal our top picks so you can get glam with ease.

There’s nothing like making a chic statement with your favorite flight liner - getting ready in minutes and looking confident all day long! With this blog post, you won't have to spend time researching different products or worry about choosing something that won't last. Instead, you'll learn what caked liners beauty buffs swear by and have access to amazing looks any day of the week!

Read this post today for insight into the best cake eyeliners on the market!

How We Choose the Best Cake Eyeliner

Cake eyeliners are a great alternative to traditional liquid or pencil eyeliners. They're easy to use and can create a wide variety of looks.

The only problem is that it can be hard to find the best cake eyeliner for you. There are so many brands and products on the market, it's tough to know which one will work best for you.

I've done all the hard work for you and have found the best cake eyeliners on Amazon. I've read thousands of reviews so that you don't have to, and have compiled a list of my top five picks.

Pro Cake Eyeliner Powder, Long Lasting Water-Soluble Eyeliner Pressed Powder, Waterproof, Smudge-Proof, Cruelty Free for Makeup Beginner and Pro Makeup Artist 0.12Oz(Black)

Check Price On Amazon!

Cool Facts

Discover the intense, long-lasting eye look of your dreams with SACE LADY Eyeliner, Pro Cake Eyeliner Powder! With an unrivaled waterproof formula that is easy to dry and won't flake throughout the day, you'll be sure to make a lasting impression. The black cake eyeliner glides easily and smoothly on the lash line for a clean, smudge-proof line that won't transfer, making it perfect for stage or everyday wear.

Plus, with unique dark blue and purple shades, you can take your eyes to a whole new level. And because this formula is equipped with a sealant and resistant against even the highest of temperatures, you can rest assured that your dazzling look will stay in place all day. Amp up your makeup bag with alluring looks that last, thanks to SACE LADY Eyeliner, Pro Cake Eyeliner Powder!

Get Informed

SACE LADY Eyeliner, Pro Cake Eyeliner Powder is the perfect choice for anyone looking for precise and long-lasting wear. This highly pigmented pressed powder eyeliner is water-based and can be applied with a damp brush for easy application. It has a unique waterproof formula that dries quickly and won't flake or smudge. This cake eyeliner is perfect for creating a natural and smooth line with an intense color payoff that will stay on all day long.

For an even more defined look, use the cake eyeliner sealant. The dark blue and purple color option is great for creating an intense and bold eye look. Whether you're a makeup beginner or a pro makeup artist, this cake eyeliner is sure to give you the perfect look.

Water Activated Pressed Powder; Gluten & Cruelty-Free

Check Price On Amazon!

Cool Facts

Introducing the newest makeup must-have: Pure Zivaª Black Matte Cake Eyeliner & Eyeshadow. This luxe formula is perfect for creating dramatic, beautiful eyes that will turn heads for all the right reasons.

This versatile pressed shadows come in a matte black shade that’s intensely pigmented for long-lasting, beautiful looks. The easy application ensures a smooth glide for tight lining or creating show-stopping winged eyes. And don't worry about fading: this smudge-proof and flake-free formula will keep you looking stunning all day long without fail.

What's more, Pure Zivaª Black Matte Cake Eyeliner & Eyeshadow is hypoallergenic, vegan friendly, and gluten-free - meaning it's great even for those with sensitive skin and allergies. And because they don't test on animals or use any animal products in their formulas, this product is completely cruelty-free.

Live your best life knowing you're glamming up without compromising your ethics and values. Get gorgeous eye makeup with Pure Zivaª Black Matte Cake Eyeliner & Eyeshadow today!

Get Informed

Pure Zivaª Black Matte Cake Eyeliner & Eyeshadow is the perfect addition to any makeup bag. It's completely cruelty-free and never tested on animals, making it a great choice for those looking for a more ethical product. The highly pigmented formula provides intense color payoff, perfect for tight lining or creating a swooping wing eye.

It won't irritate your eyes or burn like some other eyeliners, making it ideal for those with contact lenses. Furthermore, Pure Ziva is free of gluten and vegan-friendly! This cake eyeliner has a matte finish that will give you the perfect look while lasting all day long. Perfect for makeup beginners and pros alike, Pure Ziva is sure to be a staple in your beauty routine.

Cool Facts

Get ready to make a statement with Jolie Extra Long-Wear Cake Eyeliner. This must-have is perfect for achieving an intensely pigmented, long-lasting look. The easy swipe application ensures you get a beautiful opaque coverage that won't budge throughout the day—even if emotions or activities put it to the test! It is transfer and smudge-resistant formula won't let you down, making it great for everyone, from those starting in makeup to industry professionals.

With its special sealant, you'll be able to achieve even more defined eye looks that will stay put all day long. Whether you're aiming for a simple yet effective casual look or want something bolder and braver—Jolie Extra Long-Wear Cake Eyeliner gives you everything you need for perfect eyes all day every day. So go on and feel confident knowing your makeup will stay with no effort all day long!

Get Informed

Jolie Extra Long-Wear Cake Eyeliner is the perfect choice for those looking for intense, long-lasting eyeliner. With tremendous staying power and a richly pigmented formulation, this black matte cake eyeliner will stay put all day long. The color goes on smoothly and with great opacity so that one swipe over your lid is all you need.

Jolie's smudge and transfer-resistant formula ensures that the color stays perfect even at the end of a long day. For an even longer-lasting look, you can use this cake eyeliner sealant to lock in the color and make it last even longer. Whether you're looking for a natural everyday look or bold, dramatic eyes, Jolie Extra Long-Wear Cake Eyeliner is sure to be your go-to!

Professional Cake Eye Liner - Professional Size 0.18oz (Stark White)

Check Price On Amazon!

Cool Facts

Get the perfect eyeliner look with Graftobian Professional Cake Eye Liner. Giving you intense color payoff with just one swipe, your eyes will be sure to turn heads and shine brightly throughout the day. The larger-than-usual size and special formula help ensure that this eyeliner will stay put all day long, giving you peace of mind while wearing it.

For an even more dramatic look, Graftobian Professional Cake Eye Liner can be mixed with water or Magic Set Lining Liquid and used with a No. 2 Round Lining Brush for best results - so you can push the limits of your style! Women everywhere know the importance of their eye makeup; with Graftobian Professional Cake Eye Liner, get ready to get compliments all night and feel confident in your natural beauty.

Get Informed

Graftobian Professional Cake Eye Liner is a must-have for makeup artists and makeup lovers alike. Perfect for film, television, bridal, and photography looks, this professional-size cake eyeliner will give you the intense color payoff that you're looking for.

This high-quality cosmetics brand is designed to be effective while being accessible to all users at a fair cost. Graftobian's Professional Cake Eye Liner is made right here in the USA and has a larger size than you're used to with other brands, allowing for extra longevity. For best results, mix with water or Magic Set Lining Liquid and use a No. 2 Round Lining Brush for precise lining results. Create perfect eyes with Graftobian Professional Cake Eye Liner!

3 Color Split Cake Retro Liner, Face & Body Paint Palette - Water Activated, Eyeliner, Aqua Graphic Liner, Professional SFX Makeup, Special Effects, 8g (Frost)

Check Price On Amazon!

Cool Facts

Welcome to Gavissi Beauty’s 3-Color Split Cake Retro Liner! Transform your look into something unique and bold with this plant-derived, water-activated vegan product. Whether you’re creating artwork on your face or body, this Retro Liner is exactly the customized palette you need to express yourself!

Just a small amount of water control is all it takes to activate the colors for an opaque, highly pigmented application - perfect for long hours and that stand out ‘wow’ factor! You can use each color separately or together to craft your masterpieces that capture your flair.

Once dry, don’t worry about smudging: this formula is smudge and transfer resistant so you can trust Gavissi Beauty Retro Liner won’t let you down. And when it comes to removal, warm soap and water do the trick! So go ahead; get daring with bright rainbow hues or be slightly subtler with corals, blues and pinks - unleash your creative side knowing Gavissi Beauty has got your back with this game-changing 3-Color Split Cake Retro Liner!

For even longer-lasting results, use a light layer of Multi-Use Primer or your preferred lash glue as a base before applying the paint on top. Get creative today - the possibilities are endless!

Get Informed

Gavissi Beauty 3 Color Split Cake Retro Liner is the perfect way to express yourself! This cruelty-free and vegan product is water-activated, allowing you to control the color intensity by adjusting the amount of water used. Once dry, it is smudge and transfer resistant, making it ideal for creating multi-colored designs with a sponge applicator or a large flat brush.

Not only that, but the highly pigmented application is also mixable to create your unique shades. For even more staying power, use a light layer of Multi-Use Primer or your preferred lash glue as a base before applying the paint. Gavissi Beauty 3 Color Split Cake Retro Liner is a must-have for any makeup enthusiast!

Tightline Cake Eye Liner, Black Ebony (CLM02502)

Check Price On Amazon!

Cool Facts

Add a touch of boldness to your everyday look with Laura Mercier Tightline Cake Eye Liner! This luxurious smudge and the transfer-resistant liner will make your eye color stand out in any light, giving you the confidence you need to take on the day. Its unique applicator glides on smoothly, providing precise coverage without drying out your lids.

Perfect for creating full and defined eyes, this high-quality eyeliner is long-lasting, so you can feel secure knowing that it won’t fade or unravel throughout the day. Make a statement with your eyes and embrace the natural beauty that comes with wearing Laura Mercier Tightline Cake Eye Liner. Don’t be afraid to add extra oomph to any look – no matter what occasion you’re headed to! With this versatile eyeliner in your makeup bag, showing off those beautiful eyes of yours has never been easier.

Get Informed

Laura Mercier Tightline Cake Eye Liner is a must-have for all makeup lovers! This long-lasting eyeliner creates defined and bold eyes with just one swipe. Its smudge and the transfer-resistant formula glides on the upper lash line smoothly and stays all day without drying out the delicate skin around your eyes. The unique applicator gives precise and full coverage color application so you can create your desired look.

The creamy, rich texture also leaves a lightweight yet bold demi-matte finish that is sure to add drama to any look. For added staying power, this eyeliner is made in the United States with quality ingredients and has been tested by dermatologists for safety. With Laura Mercier Tightline Cake Eye Liner, you can create perfect eyeliner looks with ease!

Cake Eyeliner FAQ

Cake eyeliner is a popular type of eyeliner that can be applied in a variety of ways to create several looks. It can be intimidating if you've never used it before. It's easy to end up with raccoon eyes if you're not careful.

So, we've put together this list of the most frequently asked questions about cake eyeliner so that you can learn how to use it like a pro.

What Is a Cake Eyeliner?

Cake eyeliner is a type of makeup that comes in the form of a compact containing an array of color pigments. The colors are usually arranged in stripes and can be used to create unique patterns on the eyes, lips, or cheeks. Cake eyeliners offer greater control over product placement and intensity than other types of eye makeup.

How Is Cake Eyeliner Different From Regular Eyeliner?

Regular eyeliner typically comes in the form of a pencil, liquid, or gel. Cake eyeliners come in a compact and are applied with a brush. The colors in water-activated liner tend to be more intense and longer-lasting than regular types of liner. You can also mix and match colors to create unique looks!

What Is the Best Way to Apply Cake Eyeliner?

The best way to apply cake eyeliner is by dipping a thin liner brush into the powder and tapping off any excess before applying. This will ensure that you don’t have too much product on your brush, resulting in a more natural look. Start in the inner corner of your eye and work your way outwards in thin strokes, gradually increasing the intensity as desired. For a more dramatic look, try blending different colors together!

What Is the Best Brush to Use for Applying Cake Eyeliner?

The best brush to use for applying cake eyeliner is an angled liner brush. It should be made of synthetic bristles, as natural bristles may absorb too much product. An angled liner brush gives you the most control when applying the eyeliner and helps to create a precise line.

What Are the Benefits of Cake Eyeliner?

Cake eyeliner has many benefits. It is long-wearing and smudge-resistant, so it won’t need to be reapplied throughout the day. It is also waterproof, meaning that it will stay in place even if you go for a swim or get caught in the rain. Additionally, cake liners give you the ability to create unique, bold looks with just one product.

What Are Some of the Best Cake Eyeliner Tips and Tricks?

Cake eyeliner can be tricky to apply if you’re new to it, but here are some tips and tricks that will help:

- Always use a primer before applying cake eyeliner to ensure that it stays in place all day.

- If you make a mistake while applying your eyeliner, use a cotton swab dipped in makeup remover to carefully remove any excess product.

- To create a more dramatic look, use multiple colors of water-activated liners and blend them together with a brush.

- Use an angled liner brush for the most precise application.

- Set your cake eyeliner with a setting powder to make it last even longer.

How to Choose the Right Cake Eyeliner For You?

Choosing the right cake eyeliner for you comes down to a few key factors:

- What type of look are you trying to achieve? Do you want something subtle or something more dramatic?

- What is your skin tone and hair color? Certain colors may be more flattering on certain complexions.

- Is the product waterproof? This is important if you plan on wearing the eyeliner in humid or wet conditions.

- Is the formula smudge-resistant? You want your liner to stay put all day long!

Cake eyeliners can be an intimidating product, but with a little practice and these tips and tricks, you’ll be able to use it like a pro. Experiment with different colors and looks and find what works best for you!

What Are Some of the Best Cake Eyeliner Dupes?

If you’re looking for a more affordable alternative to cake liners, there are some great dupes available. The NYX Professional Makeup Vivid Brights Eyeliner and the e.l.f. Intense Ink Eyeliner offers a high-intensity color payoff with a long-lasting, waterproof formula that won’t budge! Additionally, the L’Oreal Paris Infallible Paints Eyeliner has a creamy, blendable formula that is perfect for creating bold looks.

Bottom Line

With this blog post, you now have all the information you need to make an informed decision when it comes to choosing cake eyeliner. Whether you're looking for a waterproof formula or something with a bit more color, there's an option on this list that is sure to suit your needs. I hope this helps make your beauty shopping decisions easier and inspires you to always pick options that work best for YOU and YOUR unique makeup routine. Ultimately, cake eyeliner can be an easy and fun way to take your eye looks to the next level, so don't be afraid to experiment and have fun with it!

We hope you find your next Groovy thing from the list above! Each product was independently selected by our editors. Some may have been sent as samples for us to fiddle with, but all opinions in this article are our own. Oh, and FYI — MyGroovyGuide may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to buy something (that's how we stay in business). Reviews have been edited for length and clarity. Have fun finding hip, cool stuff you will LOVE!